%20(2).png)
The Gymshark Playbook: How To Scale Your Brand Through Community
- 3 days ago
- 8 min read
In conversation with Elfried Samba, Co-founder & CEO of Butterfly Effect | Hosted by James Sutcliffe
What does it actually take to build a community that becomes a commercial moat? Not a following, not an audience - a community that defends your brand, sells for you, and compounds your growth year after year? That was the question at the heart of our latest founder session, where we were joined by Elfried Samba: the architect of Gymshark's social and community strategy during its journey from an £8 million business to a £1.4 billion brand.
Elfried is now co-founder and CEO of Butterfly Effect, a growth consultancy that teaches the community-compounding frameworks he developed at Gymshark to the next generation of founders and scale-ups. Over 90 minutes, in a candid conversation with our founder James Sutcliffe and live Q&A with our network, Elfried shared frameworks, principles, and hard-won lessons that challenge most conventional thinking about marketing, loyalty, and growth.
What follows are the most impactful takeaways for founders looking to turn their customer base into a meaningful and durable moat.
The Funnel Is Only Half the Picture
Most brands obsess over the top of the funnel: awareness, consideration, conversion. Elfried's argument is that this is where the real work begins, not ends.
At Gymshark, they turned the traditional funnel into an hourglass - adding three additional stages below conversion:
Advocacy
Earning trusted recommendations from people who have bought from you or heard about you.
Defensibility
Repeated sales, and customers who come to your defence when the brand is attacked.
Community
The consistent, compounding intersection of all three, sustained over time.
"The goal is to make sure the proximity between the brand and the community never widens, even as you grow. That's the biggest thing that happens. Brands forget the people that got them where they are in pursuit of investors and quarterly targets."
This framing has a direct commercial consequence: community is your brand's life insurance. Unlike paid media, which creates short-term breathing room but shortens your long-term lifespan as costs compound and returns diminish, community creates salespeople on your behalf at no marginal cost.
The Paid Media Drug and Its Long-Term Cost
One of Elfried's sharpest warnings was about the trap he calls the "paid media drug." Put £1 in, get £10 out, and so you double down. It feels rational. But it is eroding your brand's lifespan from the inside.
Paid media costs rise over time. Attention is harder to buy. And the moment cash flow tightens, brand investment is the first thing cut - precisely when you need it most. Elfried's advice: carve out a fixed brand budget that cannot be touched, regardless of short-term performance. Think of paid media as your salary, and brand investment as your pension.
He was equally clear about the competitive window founders are operating in. Technical moats have a shelf life of months now, not years. AI has collapsed the barrier to building an MVP. The only three things that are genuinely hard to copy are:
Community > Distribution > Data
"If you don't have those three things, anybody can copy you tomorrow."
The Jab, Jab, Jab Framework - Earning the Right to Sell
At Gymshark, they only ran hard sales twice a year - the summer sale and Black Friday. The rest of the year was spent giving value: building trust, building culture, building desire. Elfried described this as living by Gary Vaynerchuk's jab, jab, jab, right hook model - 80-90% value, 10-20% sell.
The effect was transformative: sales days felt like events. Product launches felt like cinema releases. Gymshark never advertised products for their functional benefits - sweat-wicking technology, materials, fit. They advertised them for their human benefits: the story, the moment, the identity.
"We turned products into moments. We didn't talk about products unless there was a human benefit."
The practical implication for founders: if you're always selling, you're training your audience to only engage when there's a deal. Build the relationship first. The revenue follows.
Actions First, Storytelling Second
This was one of the session's most striking themes, and one Elfried returned to repeatedly: the era of the emotive brand film with a piano soundtrack and a sweeping message is over. Not because storytelling doesn't matter, but because words and actions have become decoupled and audiences can feel it.
He pointed to a telling example: during Covid, he saw 25 brands run near-identical "we're all in this together" campaigns back to back - many of whom then laid off thousands of people. When actions and words don't match, it doesn't just fail to build community. It actively destroys trust.
His framework for building trust at scale is ECD:
Experience: what your brand actually does and how it behaves in the world.
Content: the documentation of those experiences and actions.
Distribution: getting those documented actions in front of the right people.
The sequencing matters: do something worth talking about, capture it, then distribute it. Don't start with the story and work backwards. The best brands have more people talking about them than they have talking about themselves.
He pointed to New York Mayor Zohran Mamdani as a contemporary case study - a political figure who built mass community trust not through polished campaign messaging, but by showing up on social platforms his constituents actually used, announcing policies he had already delivered rather than promises he intended to keep.
Depth Over Width - Own a Niche Before You Try to Scale It
One of the most counter-intuitive pieces of advice in the session concerned focus. At Gymshark, even as the brand grew towards unicorn status, Elfried pushed back internally against plans to diversify beyond bodybuilding. His argument: they hadn't even solved language yet. They were barely penetrating the French-speaking and Spanish-speaking markets.
He referenced the Steve Jobs story of his mentor throwing five pieces of paper at him at once - impossible to catch. The best brands have one message, delivered three ways. Depth, not width, is what creates real community.
If your total addressable market is just 1% of the global population, that's 80 million people. At a £10 average basket, that's £800 million. But most founders are too scared to focus on their 1%.
A marketing strategy is three things.
How do you build fame? How do you become easy to find? How do you become hard to leave? Community is the answer to all three.
Influencer Strategy - You're Buying Access to a Community, Not an Audience
Gymshark's approach to ambassadors was categorically different from how most brands use influencers. The industry default is transactional: one campaign, measure the conversion, move on. Elfried described this as the current state of dating - non-committal, short-termist, and almost never effective.
Gymshark's model was long-term advocacy. Find people whose values, personality and community align with what you want your brand to stand for; test them over 90 days; then work with the best ones for years, with the specific goal of turning their followers into your followers.
Two common mistakes he called out:
Telling creators what to do. "That's like going to their house and telling them how to redecorate it. It's no longer their home. People can feel that."
Expecting one post to convert. Trust cannot be built in a single interaction. If the first campaign didn't convert, the problem is almost always insufficient touchpoints, not the wrong influencer.
Think of an influencer as a gateway to a community, not as a broadcast channel. The influence is what matters and the person is just the medium.
Distribution Is a Skill and Most Brands Are Terrible at It
Social platforms are echo chambers. Getting in front of your own followers is hard. Getting in front of new audiences is harder. Great content is not enough if you can't distribute it.
He introduced the concept of clipping, a practice borrowed from the world of large YouTube creators and streamers, where armies of social-first editors take long-form content and recut it into platform-native, highly shareable clips. The biggest streamers in the world spend millions on this. The film Sinners - which generated close to $400 million globally - was driven not by its official trailer but by a clipper-led distribution strategy that made the film feel unmissable across every corner of social media.
The broader principle is that virality can be reverse engineered. You don't wait to go viral, you build the infrastructure to make it happen.
His advice for platform strategy was to resist the temptation to be everywhere. Be like the same person in a library, a concert and a church - same person, different behaviour. Master one platform before you build the wider ecosystem.
ROI of Community - The Metrics That Actually Matter
When James pressed on how founders should measure community, Elfried cut through to the commercial fundamentals:
Lifetime value (LTV): the single most important indicator that community is working.
Customer acquisition cost (CAC) relative to competitors: if you're spending three times more to acquire the same customer as a brand with community, you will lose.
Defensibility: what happens to your brand when something goes wrong. Gymshark's Black Friday meltdown should have been a brand disaster. Instead, customers were empathetic and stayed loyal. That moat was built before the crisis.
"Community is the vehicle to making sure that you don't spend as much to earn. Very simply put."
He also framed community as the answer to what he called the TSD question every brand strategy should start with:
What do you want people to Think? What do you want them to Say? What do you want them to Do?
Everything else - platform, format, influencer selection - is downstream of having clear answers to those three questions.
Every Brand Is in the Trust Business
One of Elfried's recurring themes was this: strip away all the jargon, the tactics and the trends, and what you are left with is simple. Every brand - B2C or B2B, product or service, consumer or enterprise - is in the trust and relationship business.
The difference between B2C and B2B is just the unit of trust. In B2C, you build trust one-to-one. In B2B, you build trust with an individual who then has to convince a wider group. The tactics differ; the underlying logic doesn't.
And in a world where IQ has been democratised, where everyone has access to the same information, the same AI tools, the same analysis, EQ is the differentiator. The brands that win will be the ones that make people feel seen, heard and supported. That is not a soft metric. That is the commercial moat.
"If you want to build community or trust or advocacy, make other people cool. If you want to build the biggest business in the world, make other people money. Give people that feeling of being seen, heard and looked after — and they will reward you tenfold."
Practical First Steps for Founders on a Tight Budget
James closed the formal part of the session by asking the practical question that was on most people's minds: for a founder slightly earlier in their journey, with limited budget, what do you actually do first?
Start with UGC. User-generated content can be sourced for a few hundred pounds. If your briefing is sharp and your taste is good, UGC gives you raw material immediately.
Turn your paid media more creative. If you're already spending on paid, shift your assets to be brand-led rather than conversion-led.
Identify your community. Who are you actually trying to earn the trust of? Who currently holds that trust? Find the creators, meme pages and publishers that represent the flat you can rent before you try to buy the mansion.
Listen before you speak. Go on LinkedIn (or wherever your buyer lives), find 20 of them, look at what they're reacting to, and build your content matrix from that. The algorithm will reward you for feeding people what they already want.
Meet people where they're selfish, not where you're selfish. The most common mistake founders make is building the world they imagine their customer lives in, rather than going to find the world their customer actually lives in.
One Final Thought
Elfried closed with something that felt less like a tactic and more like a challenge. Community, data and distribution are no longer nice-to-haves. They are survival infrastructure. The founders who build that infrastructure now before they need it, are the ones who will have the moat that matters when everything else becomes commoditised.
"You're never going to be younger than you are today. You're never going to have as much energy as you have today — as a brand and as a founder. Time doesn't get better. Start now."
A full recording of our session with Elfried is now available to watch on our YouTube channel.
Check out more of our upcoming events.
